Suicide by Star Wars Apocrypha: Zayne Carrick Lives—and so Does Our Bad Luck!

The Secret Journal of Doctor Demagol

Author: John Jackson Miller

Medium: Short Story

Publication Date: April 2010 on (republished on Unbound Worlds)

Timeline Placement: 3,964 – 3,963 BBY

This first-person series of journal entries spans the entire run of the Knights of the Old Republic comic and retells many scenes from Demagol’s point of view, in addition to revealing what he was up to while off-screen. Unlike the previous two KotOR shorts, “Labor Pains” and “Interference,” which didn’t really bring much to the table beyond being fun diversions, this story offers new insights on Demagol’s behavior and thought process while disguised as Rohlan and alleviates the lack of overt characterization caused by his subterfuge.

There are a few points of interest that change things we thought we knew from the comics. When Demagol calls up Mandalore to invite him to Adasca’s auction, he lets him know who he really is instead of sticking to the Rohlan disguise. So when Mandalore gives him the new suit of armor that Demagol promptly throws away, it adds kind of a little comedic twist on the scene. I guess not really though.

There’s also a line where Demagol muses how Squint would be lucky to leave his laboratory with nothing more than an elongated spine. I’m not sure if this is supposed to be an explanation on Miller’s part for why Malak is so much taller in the videogame than in the comic or just a callback to Alek’s joke in Flashpoint about being a little taller after getting off the torture rack.

At this point I don’t care, however. The best thing about this story is getting inside Demagol’s head and basically revisiting the entire series from his point of view. In that way it serves both as sort of a “greatest hits” and as an overdue exploration of a major character who we didn’t realize was a major character until shortly before he died. It’s a cool narrative device and Demagol gets a lot of great funny and/or evil lines. “It is a wonder anyone is ever born.”

4/5 Death Stars, an acceptable coda to the series.

(Suicide by Star Wars Apocrypha is a foolish attempt to examine the entirety of the now decanonized Star Wars Expanded Universe and quantify its assorted artistic merits. Read the introduction. Check out the archives.)

  • DarthYan

    are we ever gonna get a sequel to this? Because there’s a lot of apocrypha

    • Leonidas

      Like the Invasion series I deeply hope that sometimes in the future we will see some good sequels to KoToR Comics. There were 12 real years between the publishing of Crimson Empire II & III. We have to be optimistic. But sadly Disney seems not to be interested in “legends” lore.